Buyback math · Explainer
The buyback math: restitution, the mileage offset, and a worked example
What California’s lemon law says goes into restitution, how the 120,000-mile offset formula works, and how penalties and fees fit in, with a hypothetical worked through line by line.

The short version
- If a carmaker can’t fix a new vehicle after a reasonable number of attempts, it must replace it or make restitution, and the buyer chooses which (Civ. Code § 1793.2(d)(2)).
- Restitution starts with the actual price paid or payable, including transportation and factory options, plus taxes and official fees and incidental damages. It leaves out dealer- or owner-installed non-factory items (§ 1793.2(d)(2)(B)).
- The manufacturer can subtract a usage offset: price × miles before the first repair visit for the problem ÷ 120,000 (§ 1793.2(d)(2)(C)).
- Penalties and attorney’s fees are separate pieces under § 1794. In opt-in cases, CCP § 871.27 adjusts some line items.
“Buyback” is the word everyone uses, but the statute says restitution. What does that come to in actual dollars? Here’s how the formula in California’s lemon law works, line by line, with a made-up example at the end.
Two remedies, and you pick
Under § 1793.2(d)(2), when a manufacturer or its representative can’t conform a new motor vehicle to the warranty after a reasonable number of attempts, it must “promptly” either replace the vehicle or make restitution. The statute then adds that the buyer is “free to elect restitution in lieu of replacement,” and can never be required to accept a replacement vehicle. A lessee counts as a buyer here (§ 1793.2(d)(2)(D)). See Leased a lemon?
What goes into restitution
Section 1793.2(d)(2)(B) sets the amount: the “actual price paid or payable by the buyer,” broken down like this.
| Item | In or out? |
|---|---|
| Price of the vehicle, paid or still payable | In |
| Transportation (destination) charges | In |
| Manufacturer-installed options | In |
| Non-manufacturer items installed by the dealer or the buyer | Out |
| Collateral charges: sales or use tax, license fees, registration fees, other official fees | In |
| Incidental damages under § 1794, such as reasonable repair, towing, and rental-car costs actually incurred | In |
The word “payable” matters for financed cars. Restitution isn’t limited to what you’ve paid so far; it also covers what you still owe on the purchase. That’s why a buyback on a financed vehicle usually includes paying off the lender. Exactly which finance charges count has been argued over in court, so treat that piece as fact-specific.
The usage offset
The manufacturer may reduce restitution by the amount “directly attributable to use by the buyer” before the buyer first delivered the vehicle to the manufacturer, distributor, or its authorized repair facility for the problem that turned out to be the nonconformity. The statute gives the formula (§ 1793.2(d)(2)(C)):
offset = price paid or payable (with transportation and factory options) × miles before the first repair visit for the problem ÷ 120,000
Three details are worth noticing:
- The miles are counted at the first repair visit for that problem, not at the buyback date. Miles you put on the car afterward, during repeat repair visits, don’t increase the offset.
- The price in the formula is narrower than the restitution total. It includes transportation and manufacturer-installed options, but the statute doesn’t add taxes, fees, or incidental damages to it.
- “First” can be disputed. If an early visit mentioned the symptom in different words, the two sides may disagree about which visit started the clock. That’s one more reason the repair order wording matters.
The same paragraph covers replacement. A buyer who takes a replacement is liable only for the usage offset on the replaced vehicle, and the manufacturer pays the taxes and official fees on the replacement plus incidental damages (§ 1793.2(d)(2)(A), (C)).
A worked example (hypothetical)
All numbers are made up, to show the arithmetic only:
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Vehicle price, including destination and factory options | $42,000 |
| Dealer-installed window tint (non-manufacturer item) | excluded |
| Sales tax, registration, and other official fees | $4,300 |
| Towing and rental costs actually incurred | $350 |
| Restitution before offset | $46,650 |
| Offset: $42,000 × 9,000 miles ÷ 120,000 | − $3,150 |
| Restitution after offset | $43,500 |
In this example the car first went in for the problem at 9,000 miles. If it had gone in at 3,000 miles, the offset would be $42,000 × 3,000 ÷ 120,000 = $1,050. On a financed car, part of the total would typically go to the lender to pay off the loan, and the rest to the buyer. Real cases get messier, with disputed fees, add-ons, and interest, and nothing here predicts what any particular case would produce.
Trade-ins don’t shrink it
What if you already traded the car in or sold it? In Niedermeier v. FCA US LLC (2024) 15 Cal.5th 792, the California Supreme Court held that a trade-in credit or sale proceeds don’t reduce statutory restitution, at least where the consumer was forced to trade in or sell because the manufacturer didn’t comply with the Act.
Beyond restitution: penalties and fees
- Willful violations. If the buyer proves the manufacturer’s failure to comply was willful, a judgment may add a civil penalty of up to two times actual damages (§ 1794(c)).
- A second penalty path. Section 1794(e) allows a penalty of up to two times damages for a violation of the refund-or-replace rule without proving willfulness. It has conditions: it doesn’t apply if the manufacturer maintains a qualified dispute-resolution program; the buyer must first serve a written notice requesting compliance; and there’s no penalty if the manufacturer complies within 30 days. You can’t recover both penalties for the same violation.
- Attorney’s fees and costs. A buyer who prevails recovers reasonable costs and attorney’s fees based on actual time spent (§ 1794(d)).
If your carmaker opted in
For manufacturers that elected the 2025 procedures, CCP § 871.27 changes some lines. Third-party add-ons, service contracts, and GAP coverage aren’t recoverable (the same items from the selling dealer are). The manufacturer gets an offset for negative equity rolled in from a prior car. Manufacturer rebates aren’t counted in the price paid. And future loan interest you won’t owe after payoff isn’t included. The pre-suit notice and the 30/60-day offer window are in § 871.24. See Did your carmaker opt in?
Where to go from here
The formula is simple; applying it isn’t always. For advice about your own vehicle, consider talking with a licensed California attorney who handles consumer warranty cases. The State Bar lists certified lawyer referral services.
Sources
- Civil Code § 1793.2 (replacement, restitution, offset formula)
- Civil Code § 1794 (incidental damages, civil penalties, attorney’s fees)
- Code of Civil Procedure § 871.27 (restitution adjustments in opt-in cases)
- Code of Civil Procedure § 871.24 (pre-suit notice; 30/60-day window)
- Niedermeier v. FCA US LLC (2024) 15 Cal.5th 792, Supreme Court of California case page
Statutory text checked on leginfo.legislature.ca.gov on Nov 15, 2026.




