Lemon law · The basics
Is my car a lemon? How California’s lemon law actually works
The Song-Beverly Act can make a carmaker replace or buy back a defective new car. Since 2025 there’s a second rulebook, but it applies only if the manufacturer opted in.

The short version
- If a carmaker can’t fix a warranty defect in a new vehicle after a reasonable number of tries, the law says it must replace the vehicle or pay restitution, and the buyer gets to choose restitution.
- Within 18 months or 18,000 miles, certain repair histories create a legal presumption that the carmaker had enough chances.
- A 2024 law (AB 1755), reshaped in 2025 (SB 26), created new pre-suit procedures. They apply only to manufacturers that elected them, and the carmaker has to tell you at the sale which rules cover your vehicle.
- Used cars sold with only what’s left of the factory warranty generally aren’t “new motor vehicles” under the buyback rule, per the California Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Rodriguez v. FCA US.
Same problem, third trip to the dealer, and you’re wondering if this is what a lemon looks like. Here’s what California’s law actually says.
“Lemon law” is the everyday name for part of the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, which begins at Civil Code section 1790. Most of the Act covers consumer warranties in general. The provisions most people mean when they say “lemon law” deal with one situation: a new vehicle that keeps going back to the dealer for a problem that never really gets fixed.
The core rule: repair, or replace or refund
The key sentence is in Civil Code § 1793.2(d)(2). If the manufacturer or its representative in California can’t make a new motor vehicle conform to its express warranty “after a reasonable number of attempts,” the manufacturer must either promptly replace the vehicle or promptly make restitution. The statute then adds that “the buyer shall be free to elect restitution in lieu of replacement.” In other words, the carmaker can’t make you take a replacement.
A defect has to be serious enough to count. The statute calls it a “nonconformity,” meaning one that “substantially impairs the use, value, or safety” of the vehicle to the buyer or lessee (§ 1793.22(e)(1)). A rattle in the glovebox probably isn’t one. A transmission that slips on the freeway might be. Lessees are covered too: the same subdivision says a “buyer” includes a lessee of a new motor vehicle (§ 1793.2(d)(2)(D)).
What counts as a “new motor vehicle”
The definition in § 1793.22(e)(2) is narrower and stranger than most people expect:
- Personal use. A new vehicle bought or used mainly for personal, family, or household purposes.
- Small business use. A new vehicle under 10,000 pounds gross vehicle weight, bought or used mainly for business by a person or entity that has no more than five motor vehicles registered in California.
- Demonstrators and dealer-owned vehicles. These are covered when sold “with a manufacturer’s new car warranty.”
- Motor homes, partly. The chassis and the part that moves the vehicle are covered. The living quarters are not.
- Not a “new motor vehicle”: motorcycles, and vehicles that aren’t registered because they are used only off the highway. (They’re left out of the new-car definition and its presumption; the general Song-Beverly warranty rules are a separate question.)
The used-car question was settled in 2024. In Rodriguez v. FCA US, LLC (Cal. Supreme Court, S274625), the court held that a used car sold with an unexpired balance of the original manufacturer’s warranty is not a “new motor vehicle” for purposes of the refund-or-replace rule. Used and certified pre-owned buyers may still have rights under other warranty law. They just aren’t covered by this particular buyback provision.
“Reasonable number of attempts” and the 18/18 presumption
The statute doesn’t define “reasonable.” But the Tanner Consumer Protection Act, Civil Code § 1793.22(b), creates a presumption that applies when, within 18 months of delivery or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first, any one of these happens:
| Trigger | What the statute requires |
|---|---|
| Safety defect | The same nonconformity is “likely to cause death or serious bodily injury if the vehicle is driven,” has been subject to repair two or more times, and the buyer has directly notified the manufacturer at least once. |
| Repeat defect | The same nonconformity has been subject to repair four or more times, and the buyer has directly notified the manufacturer at least once. |
| Days in the shop | The vehicle has been out of service for repairs for a cumulative total of more than 30 calendar days since delivery. |
Three details matter. First, the direct-notice requirement applies only if the manufacturer “clearly and conspicuously disclosed” it in the warranty or owner’s manual. Second, the presumption is rebuttable, so the manufacturer can argue against it. Third, it isn’t the only way in. A vehicle outside the 18/18 window can still qualify if the number of attempts was unreasonable on the facts.
Some manufacturers sponsor a state-certified arbitration program. If one exists and you were properly told about it, § 1793.22(c) says you must use it before you can rely on the presumption. Its decisions bind the manufacturer only if the buyer accepts them (§ 1793.22(d)(2)). The California Department of Consumer Affairs runs the Arbitration Certification Program, which oversees these programs.
What “restitution” includes
Under § 1793.2(d)(2)(B), restitution equals the actual price paid or payable, including transportation charges and manufacturer-installed options. It excludes non-manufacturer items a dealer or the buyer installed. It also includes collateral charges such as sales tax, license and registration fees, and other official fees, plus incidental damages like reasonable repair, towing, and rental-car costs.
The manufacturer may subtract a usage offset for the miles driven before the vehicle first went in for the problem. Section 1793.2(d)(2)(C) spells out the formula:
offset = price paid or payable × (miles before first repair visit ÷ 120,000)
A hypothetical: a $40,000 vehicle that first went in for the defect at 6,000 miles works out to $40,000 × 6,000 ÷ 120,000 = $2,000. Real calculations are often disputed, especially which visit counts as “first” and what counts as the price. The full walkthrough is in The buyback math, and leases are covered in Leased a lemon?
In Niedermeier v. FCA US LLC (2024) 15 Cal.5th 792, the Supreme Court held that a trade-in credit or sale proceeds don’t reduce statutory restitution, at least where the consumer was forced to trade in or sell the vehicle because the manufacturer didn’t comply with the Act.
Fees and penalties
Civil Code § 1794(d) lets a buyer who prevails recover costs and expenses, including attorney’s fees “based on actual time expended,” that the court finds were reasonably incurred. This fee-shifting rule is a big reason lemon-law cases exist as a field. If the buyer shows the failure to comply was willful, § 1794(c) lets the judgment add a civil penalty of up to two times actual damages. Section 1794(e) sets out a separate penalty route tied to the presumption and a written notice, and a manufacturer that keeps a qualified dispute-resolution program isn’t liable for that particular penalty. None of this guarantees any result. Whether a vehicle qualifies, and for what, depends on the facts.
The 2025 changes: AB 1755 and SB 26
This is the short version. The full walkthrough is in Did your carmaker opt in?
AB 1755 (Stats. 2024, ch. 938) added a new chapter to the Code of Civil Procedure, sections 871.20 through 871.30, with its own procedures for lemon-law cases. SB 26 (Stats. 2025, ch. 1), signed April 2, 2025, made that chapter opt-in:
- Who it covers. Under CCP § 871.29, a manufacturer may elect the new procedures for all of its vehicles sold during five consecutive calendar years. It can’t revoke the election during that period. The chapter doesn’t apply to a manufacturer’s vehicles from years its election doesn’t cover.
- You should be told at the sale. The same section requires the manufacturer, when a vehicle is sold new, to notify the consumer which set of procedures governs it.
- Public list. DCA’s Arbitration Certification Program must publish the list of electing manufacturers each year by December 15. See DCA’s New Lemon Law Procedures page and its manufacturer list.
If your manufacturer opted in
- Notice before suing for penalties. Under CCP § 871.24, at least 30 days before filing a lawsuit that seeks civil penalties under § 1794(c), the consumer must send the manufacturer written notice with their name, the VIN, and a brief repair history, and demand a repurchase or replacement. The notice goes to the email address the manufacturer posts for this purpose, or by certified or registered mail to the address in the owner’s manual or warranty booklet. The consumer must have possession of the vehicle when sending it.
- The 30/60 window. If the manufacturer offers restitution or replacement within 30 days of receiving the notice and completes it within 60 days, the civil-penalty claim can’t go forward. If it makes no offer within 30 days, the consumer may sell the vehicle and pursue remedies, subject to disclosure rules for the sale.
- Suing without notice. A consumer can still sue for restitution or replacement without sending the notice, but then can’t seek those civil penalties (§ 871.24(h)).
- Deadline. Under CCP § 871.21, an action covered by the chapter must be filed within one year after the express warranty expires, and never later than six years after original delivery, with tolling for things like time in the shop.
If your manufacturer did not opt in, the traditional Song-Beverly rules above still govern. For those claims, courts have generally looked to the four-year limitations period in Commercial Code § 2725, but when that clock starts can be argued. Don’t assume you have time to spare.
Paperwork habits that matter
More on this in Repair orders: the paperwork that decides lemon cases.
- Get a repair order for every visit, even “could not duplicate” visits. Check that it shows your complaint in your words, the mileage, and the dates in and out.
- Describe the symptom the same way each time, so the record shows it’s the same problem.
- Read the warranty booklet and owner’s manual for any direct-notice address, arbitration program, or lemon-law notice email.
- Find the paperwork from your purchase that says which procedures govern your vehicle, and compare it with DCA’s list.
- Keep making your payments. Stopping can create separate problems.
Where to go from here
For a dispute about your own vehicle, consider talking with a licensed California attorney who handles consumer warranty cases. If you don’t know one, the State Bar of California lists certified lawyer referral services. DCA’s Arbitration Certification Program explains the state-certified arbitration route.
Sources
- Civil Code § 1793.2 (refund-or-replace rule, restitution, offset formula)
- Civil Code § 1793.22 (Tanner presumption; definitions)
- Civil Code § 1794 (damages, fees, civil penalties)
- Code of Civil Procedure § 871.20 (scope of the opt-in chapter)
- Code of Civil Procedure § 871.21 (limitations period, opt-in chapter)
- Code of Civil Procedure § 871.24 (pre-suit notice; 30/60-day window)
- Code of Civil Procedure § 871.29 (manufacturer election; DCA list; notice at sale)
- Commercial Code § 2725 (four-year limitations period)
- DCA Arbitration Certification Program: New Lemon Law Procedures
- DCA ACP: manufacturers that opted in
- Supreme Court of California: Rodriguez v. FCA US (S274625)
- Supreme Court of California: Niedermeier v. FCA US (S266034)
Statutory text checked on leginfo.legislature.ca.gov on Nov 15, 2026.




